← All guides

PHI vs PII: what each means, where they overlap and why it matters for redaction

PHI and PII are often used as if they were the same thing. They are not: one is a legal category defined by HIPAA, the other a broad description of any data that identifies a person. The difference decides which rules apply to a document and what has to come out of it before it is shared or used for testing.

THE SHORT ANSWER

PHI (protected health information) is individually identifiable health information held or transmitted by a HIPAA covered entity or business associate. PII is any information that can identify a person. All PHI identifies someone, but PII becomes PHI only when it is linked to health, care or payment information held by one of those organizations.

How this page was written. GritWorks makes GritRedact, GritTransform and GritRender, so we are not neutral. What we say about other products reflects their own public websites and documentation as of 19 November 2026. We make no claims about other products' accuracy. Products change: confirm details with each vendor.

PHI vs PII at a glance

PHI (protected health information)PII (personally identifiable information)
Defined byThe HIPAA Privacy Rule (45 CFR 160.103)No single US definition; federal guidance describes information that can distinguish or trace a person's identity, alone or combined with other information
Who it applies toCovered entities (health plans, health care clearinghouses and health care providers that conduct standard electronic transactions) and their business associatesAny organization, under whichever privacy, breach-notification or sector law applies to it
What makes data qualifyHealth, care or payment information that identifies a person, held or transmitted by a covered entity or business associateAnything that identifies a person: a name, ID number, address, face, voice or a combination of details
ExamplesA lab result with a patient name, a claim form with a member ID, a discharge summary, a billing recordA passport scan, a loan application, a payslip, a customer support email, a CCTV still
How it stops being regulatedHIPAA de-identification by Safe Harbor or Expert Determination (45 CFR 164.514(b))Depends on the law; many treat data as no longer personal only when people can no longer reasonably be identified

What PHI means under HIPAA, and what PII means

PHI is individually identifiable health information that a covered entity or business associate creates, receives, maintains or transmits, in any form: paper, electronic or spoken. Health information is individually identifiable when it relates to a person's past, present or future physical or mental health or condition, the care they received, or payment for that care, and identifies them or could reasonably be used to identify them.

Three conditions have to hold together: the information is about health, care or payment; it identifies the person; and a covered entity or business associate holds it. The rule also excludes some records, such as employment records a covered entity holds in its role as employer, education records covered by FERPA, and records of people who died more than 50 years ago.

PII has no single legal definition in the US. Federal guidance describes it as information that can be used to distinguish or trace a person's identity, on its own or combined with other information that is linked or linkable to them. State privacy laws, the GDPR (which uses "personal data") and India's DPDP Act each draw their own boundaries; see the DPDP Act guide for India.

Where PHI and PII overlap in documents

Most identifiers are PII wherever they appear. They become part of PHI when they sit next to health, care or payment information held by a covered entity or business associate. The same name can be both, depending on the document and who holds it:

DocumentPHI, PII or both?
A lab report held by a diagnostics laboratoryPHI, and the patient name, date of birth and record number on it are also PII
A health insurance claim form held by the health planPHI: member ID, provider and diagnosis codes identify the person and describe care and payment
A loan application or KYC document held by a bankPII, not PHI: a bank is not a covered entity for that record
A sick note in the HR file of a hospital acting as employerPII; excluded from PHI as an employment record, though other rules may still protect it
Step counts and heart rate in a consumer app that is not a covered entity or business associateUsually PII outside HIPAA; other federal and state laws may still apply

Scanned and faxed documents add a practical overlap: PHI and PII sit in headers, stamps, handwriting, barcodes and metadata, not only in typed fields. A referral letter can carry a patient's name in the letterhead, a medical record number in a barcode and a phone number in a fax header.

HIPAA Safe Harbor's 18 identifiers, and Expert Determination

HIPAA recognizes two routes to de-identified health information, which is no longer PHI.

Safe Harbor requires removing the following 18 identifiers of the individual and of their relatives, employers and household members:

  1. Names
  2. Geographic subdivisions smaller than a state, such as street address, city, county and ZIP code (the first three ZIP digits may stay if that area holds more than 20,000 people)
  3. All elements of dates, except the year, directly related to the person (birth, admission, discharge and death dates), and all ages over 89
  4. Telephone numbers
  5. Fax numbers
  6. Email addresses
  7. Social Security numbers
  8. Medical record numbers
  9. Health plan beneficiary numbers
  10. Account numbers
  11. Certificate and license numbers
  12. Vehicle identifiers and serial numbers, including license plates
  13. Device identifiers and serial numbers
  14. Web URLs
  15. IP addresses
  16. Biometric identifiers, including finger and voice prints
  17. Full-face photographs and comparable images
  18. Any other unique identifying number, characteristic or code

Removing the identifiers is one route, and it has a second condition: the covered entity must also have no actual knowledge that the remaining information could identify the person, alone or in combination. A rare diagnosis, a job title or a free-text note can still point to someone after every listed identifier is gone.

Expert Determination is the other route. A qualified expert applies statistical or scientific methods, concludes that the risk of identifying anyone by the anticipated recipient is very small, and documents the methods and results. It can keep data that Safe Harbor would remove, such as dates or finer geography, when the analysis supports it.

Redaction alone is not HIPAA de-identification. Blacking out or removing values from a document is a technique. De-identification is an outcome that one of the two methods has to establish, with policies and validation that fit the intended use and recipient.

Why the difference matters for redaction and testing

  • It sets what has to come out. A redaction policy for PHI must cover identifiers in every layer of the file (text, page image, hidden OCR text and metadata), and the Safe Harbor list is a useful checklist even when you are not relying on that method. The PII redaction guide covers where values hide.
  • It sets who may receive what. Redaction is not authorization: if a team or vendor is not entitled to the records, block access rather than sending redacted copies.
  • Flagging is not removal. PII flagging is not redaction. A tool that labels identifiers in extracted data has not removed them from the source document.
  • Testing should not need real PHI. To test OCR, extraction or redaction, use fictional documents whose values are known in advance, such as the free diagnostics sample pack or variants generated with GritRender. Known values let you search the output for every identifier and count what was missed. The packs are a testing resource, not a free tier.

GritRedact detects and permanently removes PII and PHI from documents, images and audio, with human review before removal and an audit record. It runs offline in your environment or as sales-assisted SaaS; pricing is agreed with sales. Its output still needs a de-identification method and a process that match the intended use.

Not legal advice. This is an educational summary prepared by GritWorks, a software company, not a law firm. Whether a record is PHI, and whether a dataset is de-identified, depends on your facts; confirm with your privacy officer or counsel.

What GritWorks does not replace

  • GritWorks complements authorization, governance and e-discovery tools rather than replacing them. Access control, data catalogues, retention policy and legal review platforms keep their jobs; GritWorks prepares the documents, images and audio that move between them.
  • Redaction is not authorization. If a person or system is not entitled to a record, block access instead of sending a redacted copy.
  • Automated redaction alone is not a declaration of HIPAA de-identification. HIPAA recognizes the Safe Harbor and Expert Determination methods; policies, validation and human review must match the intended use and recipient.
  • PII flagging is not redaction. GritTransform can flag potentially sensitive values in extracted results, but that does not remove them from the source. Use GritRedact when content must be removed.
  • Engagement is sales-assisted. GritWorks has no public or self-serve API, SDK, MCP server or free tier, and publishes no price list: pricing is agreed with sales. Customer APIs are provided after onboarding.

Common questions

What is the difference between PHI and PII?

PII is any information that can identify a person. PHI is a HIPAA category: individually identifiable health information held or transmitted by a covered entity or business associate. All PHI identifies someone, but PII becomes PHI only when it is tied to health, care or payment information held by one of those organizations.

Is all PHI also PII?

Yes, in practice. PHI is identifiable by definition, so it contains or can be linked to PII. Once health information is de-identified under HIPAA, by Safe Harbor or Expert Determination, it is no longer PHI.

Is a name PHI or PII?

A name on its own is PII. It is part of PHI when it appears with health, care or payment information held by a covered entity or business associate, for example on a lab report or a claim form.

What are the 18 HIPAA identifiers?

Safe Harbor lists names, geography smaller than a state, date elements other than the year and ages over 89, phone and fax numbers, email addresses, Social Security, medical record, health plan beneficiary, account and certificate or license numbers, vehicle and device identifiers, URLs, IP addresses, biometrics, full-face photos, and any other unique identifying number, characteristic or code.

Does removing the 18 identifiers make data de-identified?

Removing them is one route, Safe Harbor, and it also requires that the covered entity has no actual knowledge that what remains could identify the person. Expert Determination is the other route. Redaction alone is not HIPAA de-identification.

Is this page legal advice?

No. It is an educational summary prepared by GritWorks, a software company, not a law firm. Confirm how HIPAA applies to your records with your privacy officer or counsel.

Start with your workflow

Put your unstructured data to work.

Tell us what your team needs to achieve. We’ll help you choose the right products, work through your requirements and explore on-premises or SaaS deployment.

Request a working session